Tiny strings-as-strings JSON in portable Erlang

There are several JSON libs for Erlang at this point, and as there is no correct mapping between JSON types and Erlang types, all make different tradeoffs that either work or don’t for your project. Beyond that, various interface and implementation differences exist due to the tradeoffs inherent in manipulating elements of the Black Tongue known as lolscript:

  • Accept values to encode as magic tagged tuples so you can specify exactly what you want VS being ambiguous
  • Never allow “naked” values (everything must be in a list/array or a map or a [whatever]) VS “hanging” values
  • Treat all strings ever as binaries because “strings are big” VS treating all strings (and binaries) as strings because strings are easy to manipulate (io_lists…)
  • Decode JSON “objects” as proplists VS decode JSON objects to dicts or maps VS add an “options” argument to the decode function
  • Encode and decode values various ways based on optional switches VS “sane defaults” (aka “works for me”)
  • Achieve lolspeed via NIFs and only work on *nix VS maintain portability via pure Erlang
  • etc.

No combination is correct for every situation, hence the proliferation of libraries. In addition to proliferation, something as simple as what is described by RFC-8259 shouldn’t require a 20k LoC dependency to manage, at least not in Erlang of all languages.

The general strings-as-strings + portability tradeoffs were made by mochiweb years ago, with mochijson2 being the go-to JSON parser for lots of projects. Now that “tuple calls” have finally been retired after years of obsolescence and deprecation, mochijson2 is finally giving up the ghost as well (as it was based on tuple calls). As a replacement that makes mostly the same tradeoffs but is arguably simpler, I wrote a single-module JSON encoder/decoder lib. It treats all strings as strings, is in pure Erlang, and is utterly boring in how simple the code is. Nothing magical to see. At all. So don’t get excited.

If you need to read things in and read things out, in JSON, and don’t really care about lolspeed but want to understand what is happening, then ZJ is for you: ZJ project @ gitlab

Note that if you have roughly the same requirements but you want to make the strings-as-binaries tradeoff then JSX is the lib for you.

 

Tags: , , , , , ,

Leave a Reply